|
||||||||||||||
Mortise and Tenon: A PrimerBy Ian KirbyJoining long grain to end grain with mortise and tenon the king of rail joints. |
||||||||||||||
|
A mortise and tenon joint is nothing more than a square peg in a square hole.
The joint is either stopped or through. The through joint is usually wedged,
which makes it effectively a dovetail joint. Chances are there isn’t a house
in the U.S.A. that doesn’t have examples of the joint somewhere in its furniture
or built-in cabinets. In this article I’ll describe the three main ways the joint is used. Since the geometry of any design follows a certain set of conditions, it’s vital to understand that aspect of the joint. I’ll also explain how to design for strength. In a subsequent article I’ll put theory into practice by looking at ways the joint can be cut and describe, through the making of a simple table, what you must do before and after cutting the joint. Although the basic joint is simple, its design details vary in complexity and sophistication according to the following circumstances: Do the two or three pieces being joined form the corner of a two-dimensional frame, as in a door, or a three-dimensional frame, as in a table? Or, do they form a T-shape, as in a center rail? And finally, is the joint through or stopped? Over the years the mortise and tenon assumed a variety of design forms for a variety of reasons. I’ve illustrated some of them along with brief comments. Regardless of their design peculiarities, to work correctly each must follow the general design characteristics of the more common forms. In many joinery situations where a mortise and tenon would have been the traditional solution, two recent alternatives have proved their worth and may be appropriate. They are plate joints and pocket screws inserted with the aid of oriented holes.
|
||||||||||||||
|
Anatomy of Parts A key step to understanding mortise and tenon joinery is knowing the parts, many of which are derived from human anatomy. The specific name of the mortise/tenon piece depends upon its function and orientation. The mortise piece is usually the upright member, such as a stile, leg, or post. The tenon piece is usually horizontal, such as a rail, an apron, a stretcher, or a shelf. |
||||||||||||||
Dimensions of Parts A = Tenon length = Mortise depthOn a stopped joint leave a gap between the end of the tenon and the bottom of the mortise. The two parts don’t need to meet since the end grain of the tenon isn’t a gluing surface, and it’s easier to make if you leave a gap of about 1/16". B = Tenon width = Mortise length Make the tenon width to exact fit. If it’s too narrow, the tenon may float and position the rail in the wrong place. For the same reason, don’t crush the edges of the tenon during assembly thinking you are making the joint tight. More likely you are causing misalignment. The end walls of the mortise are end grain and therefore not suitable gluing surfaces. C = Tenon thickness = Mortise width Make the tenon width to exact fit. If it’s too thin, it will likely float and position the rail in the wrong place. You should be able to “push fit” the parts together. A “clamp fit” with squeaky resistance is too tight. Applying glue will swell an easy-fit joint much tighter. A too-tight joint might split when glue is added. |
||||||||||||||
|
Geometry of Parts Accurate joinery, whether cut by hand or machine, is defined by accurate geometry.Some authors recommend under-cutting the shoulder to ensure a tight-fitting joint. My view is — don’t. First, what is undercut? 85°? 70°? Second, how do you measure it? Third, if you can undercut consistently, its stands to reason you can also cut square. The undercut shoulder presents an edge to the stile instead of a flat face. Clamp pressure easily pushes the edge into the stile, distorts the wood, and changes the between-the-shoulders distance. Most important, you also lose the mechanical efficiency of a dead stop. Mortise and tenon joinery is subjected to two types of stress. One type arises
from use, as when we lean back in a chair or push a table to a new location.
The other type arises from wood movement. Wood shrinks and expands across the
grain in response to changing humidity but not along its length.To cope with both types of stress, we design the joint to be as strong as possible. Since the configuration and section of the parts being joined are usually unique, we must design for the job at hand and that design is based on experience about what has worked before. |
||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||
Shoulders All tenons require shoulders. There are two types. Structural shoulders resist bending stress. Cosmetic shoulders hide the joint if the rail shrinks and they hide the gap presented by a damaged mortise end or a mortise made slightly long. Cosmetic shoulders need be only 1/8" to be effective.A tenon without a shoulder on one side is called a barefaced mortise and tenon. To keep it aligned at the glue-and-clamp stage requires purpose-made clamping blocks. I don’t recommend this configuration. If at all possible, reduce the thickness of the tenon to get a shoulder on each side. |
||||||||||||||
|
Tenon Length, Mortise Depth
Tenon Width, Mortise Length If a mortise extends too near to the end of the stile of a corner joint (often, exactly the spot where you simply need a joint to go), the stile may split. Therefore, make the tenon shoulder nearest the end of the stile one-quarter the total width of the tenon. To keep from splitting the mortise, an extra inch or so (called the horn) is left on the stile. Once the glue is cured and the job is out of clamps, the horn is sawn off.When the mortise is not at the end of the stile, make the tenon the full width of the rail, less 1/8" at each edge for the cosmetic shoulder. |
||||||||||||||
|
Tenon Thickness, Mortise Width When joining two pieces of wood of the same thickness, divide the thickness roughly in half to create a balanced joint. For example, if the wood is 3/4" thick, make the tenon 3/8" thick and each mortise cheek 3/16" thick. Since each piece has an equal amount of tissue, each is equally able to resist stress and the joint is balanced. |
||||||||||||||
|
Loose-tenon Joint
A slot mortiser is a machine that cuts a mortise into both rail and stile.
The two parts are connected with a third piece made to fit the slot, much like
a biscuit joiner. This joint is called a loose mortise and tenon. You can make
the joint using a plunge router and a single bit, although you will normally
need different jigs to manage the two parts. Once glued, the joint is just as
strong as a conventional mortise and tenon.
|
||||||||||||||
Frame and Panel Two-dimensional frames with a solid panel trapped in a groove make a classic frame and panel. This ingenious construction is not only the foundation of furniture making, it remains the only method we have for making a dimensionally stable frame from dimensionally unstable solid wood. The traditional example is, of course, the frame and panel door. Although with modern material this door is no longer the most efficient design available, tradition and a sense of history continue to drive the popularity of this beautiful cabinet staple. Used in multiples, we can make larger frames, which, joined at the corners, make storage chests and cabinets.Three-dimensional frames are used to make table bases, chairs, and the skeletons of large cases. Three members generally connect, for example, a table leg and two rails or aprons. In most situations the vertical leg is more or less square in section, while the incoming rails are flat. Factors affecting the design of the joint include the width and thickness of the rails, the exact location of the rails on the faces of the leg, and complications caused by drawers or doors.
Note that the thickness of the tenon is increased as it is inset while the gluing area decreases. In each case the tenon is mitered in the middle of the joint. Provided the tenons don’t touch, you can make the gap as small as you like. The 1/8" inside shoulder on the flush and inset rail is enough to do the job.
|
||||||||||||||
|
Underframes Underframes impart stability to a piece of furniture by bracing the structure.
They often do double duty as supports for shelves.Where two underframe members meet at a T-shaped junction, you can increase the gluing area by using twin tenons. If the joint is made through and wedged, it offers an attractive design detail.
|
||||||||||||||
Twin Tenons When the rail is thicker than 1", you can increase the gluing area by making twin tenons side by side. The total thickness of the two tenons is about the same as for a single tenon, but the doubled gluing area makes for a potentially stronger joint. The figure below shows typical proportions: the minimum thickness of each tenon is about 3/16", and the space between should be about equal the tenon thickness. Twin tenons are often used this way in chair making where a back rail joins a leg.Short twin tenons also occur in carcass sides, where a partition ties the case together and also acts as a shelf. Make the housing (also known as a dado) about 1/8" deep between the mortises. A housing between tenons not only makes the shelf able to bear a heavy load, but it also flattens any cup in the two boards. Because the tenons would otherwise be very short, they are usually made through and wedged. Because of the 1/8" deep housing, a 1/2" thick tenon is plenty big. |
||||||||||||||
Gluing and Clamping A simple yet elegant idea like the mortise and tenon joint can go wrong at the last moment. In a later article, I’ll go through the basics of gluing and clamping. But for now I must simply say that incorrectly applied clamps and their critically important clamping blocks, or cauls, will ruin the best crafted joints in short order. So do not give short shrift to this last step in making a joint. |
||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||
With these few concepts in mind, it’s time to go to your shop and join some wood. Good cutting! |
||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||