A Nutty Way of Telling Red from White Oak

A common autumnal sight is a squirrel, busily scurrying to bury his winter food supply of nuts. Have you ever thought about how much these furry little beasts have in common with woodworkers?

For one, both share a fine appreciation for oak.


Squirrels, however, may be even more discerning than woodworkers in distinguishing between the red oak and the white oak of this species. You may recall that forester Tim Knight, in his post on this blog entitled Red Oak White Oak: Telling the Difference, mentioned the different sprouting times of red and white oak acorns. What Tim didn’t mention is the “squirrel factor.”

Apparently, since white oak acorns’ natural tendency is to begin sprouting as soon as they’re in the ground, squirrels must take steps to guard against their food supply turning into trees: they bite through the seed cap to prevent sprouting.

For red oak acorns, since the germination period is longer, the squirrels don’t bother. (The apparent squirrel-brain theory is that they’re going to dig up all those acorns and eat them this winter, before they’d begin to sprout, so it’s not necessary. Now, you know and I know that they never find all of their stashes before spring, but let’s not disillusion the furry little guys, OK?)

How can they tell the difference? By the smell.

That made sense to me, since woodworker George Wurtzel, an instructor at the Minneapolis Blind, Inc. Blindness Training Center, had mentioned this summer that he and his students can also tell red and white oak apart by the sniff test. (The article on George’s program is in the August 2011 Woodworker’s Journal; a video is here.)

But it was neither George nor Tim who told me about the squirrels’ expertise: that, I discovered while reading National Geographic Little Kids First Big Book of Why.

Woodworking, like fall leaves, is everywhere.


Related posts:

This entry was posted in Blog Transfer, Outdoors, Trees and tagged by Joanna Takes. Bookmark the permalink.

About Joanna Takes

Joanna Werch Takes has been at Woodworker's Journal since 1998. Her work includes writing and editing for many print magazine departments, among them the "Stumpers" mystery tool department. Joanna is also a frequent contributor to the Woodworker's Journal eZine. Joanna's previous experience includes work as a newspaper reporter. Her woodworking has consisted of small projects such as toys and a storage box. She is active in the Women of Today service organization.

2 thoughts on “A Nutty Way of Telling Red from White Oak

  1. Too Funny ! I grew up in New Jersey so watching the Squirrels put away nuts for the winter was a ritual of fall. I had not idea they were choosing which ones … hey their squirrels, they run ¾ of a way across a road and when they see you coming in a car they reverse and run back they way they came ¾ of the way across the road.

    A few facts: New Jersey made the Red Oak its state tree in 1950 a few years before I was born, and New Jersey also boasts that their oldest White Oak in Basking Ridge was a place George Washington used to stop sit in the shade and have lunch.

    From a wood workers stand point I prefer red oak for its warmer tones and like the squirrel I can always dig up a piece in the winter to work on.

  2. Simple: Red Oak leaves have sharp points on the leaves (Think they can poke you and cause you to bleed RED) White Oak leaves have smooth points. I learned this from a hardwood saw mill owner. I haven’t found different yet. Where I live there are so many subspecies of oak it is real confusing. This simplifies it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>